Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Greeley Miklashek, MD's avatar

Thanks, Alan, for the biopic and collapse awareness. Unfortunately, you may be too optimistic. I won't go into the details in an ocean of data verifying our rapidly heating environment here, except to point to the C3S (you need to check them out) data: the GAST has risen 0.4 degC in just the past two years and appears to be on an accelerating trend line, so 0.2 degC annually, reaching 2 degC GAST by 2027, 3 degC by 2032, and an unsurviveable 6 degC by 2047, just 22 yrs. from now, so you'll be 66yo, if you're 44 now. AS you will be the last one out, please turn off the lights. Have a blessed day. Gregg (also "Greeley's Newsletter.substack.com")

Expand full comment
Jan Andrew Bloxham's avatar

Dear Alan, it's brave of you to admit to your youthful gullibility because of course this looks like a disqualifying factor re believing your "latest conspiracy theory".

Like all children, you were naturally receptive to your biggest authority figures' influence. Indoctrination of false beliefs perpetuates exactly because of this. I think any mature, honest adult can forgive you this.

It's impressive and brave of you that you didn't double down via cognitive dissonance, and broke free of the illusions. Far from everyone makes it out. Well done. The world would be a better place if people were better at embracing scepticism and critical thinking. I feel like our educational institutions -- and society as a whole -- have completely failed us in this regard.

It's morbidly fascinating to me how hard it is for people to accept the mountains of evidence regarding our trajectory. Even the consequences of the simplest part of the polycrisis - rising CO2 levels - do not truly penetrate people's minds. If they did, they would be doing as Greta thinks makes sense: panicking like their house is on fire. Clearly, they are not.

Studying psychology, sociology, and neuroscience helps us understand our malfunctions, and one could go forever about this. Like you, I felt compelled to blog about it as a form of journaling along with a desperate attempt to raise awareness.

I cannot recommend the book "Don't Even Think About It - Why Our Minds Are Wired To Ignore Climate Change" (George Marshall) enough. Not only is it the best book on the subject, but it may be the best nonfiction book I have read, period. I'm not sure if it will offer you solace, though. That is more a philosophical challenge.

Thank you for your contributions. Fwiw, your site was instrumental in raising my awareness, and I share it often. The message does get through to some.

I do think pretty everyone will be aware sooner or later -- when it's way too late to mitigate much at all. It's just a question of time. The evidence will be overwhelming when people are dying in the millions and billions.

Fwiw, I think this is further out than you and climate alarmists believe, maybe 30-60 years. That's just my personal estimate, and I can't possibly say for sure. In general, I think humans are ridiculously good at adaptation, and we may well surprise positively.

Otoh, when one looks at the polycrisis as a whole, it's just overwhelming to an absurd degree. We are already in new waters we don't even understand, and humanity has never faced such a complex challenge before. I am highly doubtful of our ability to face it. I can easily envision a future world in utter shock, despair and apathy as everything comes crashing down at once. It will be truly horrific to witness the entire world's mental suffering. The one silver lining about being collapse aware in advance is that one has preemptively despaired, and, with a little luck, reached acceptance. One will be neither surprised nor shocked. And perhaps one will, during apocalyptic times, suddenly be the robust one people need to lean on for a change.

Best wishes.

Expand full comment
22 more comments...

No posts